Ok playing from the 6th ed core book and a bunch of older supplements (since my 5.1 core book died of old age and over use) as well as some 7e stuff I've started to convert back, any ways one of the characters got a 21 on Edu (before Occupation mods, on top of an 18 Int) and the skill points he ha to throw around threaten to over balance the group dynamic given that he is a Humanities Grad Student (M.U. Go Cyclopedias!), other characters are no slouches Edu wise, we have a P.I. Grate War Vet (good Edu from life experience, at 17), a Dilettante/Flapper with Diplomas in English & Design and a Journalist/Flapper with a B.A. in Journalism and Diploma of Design (both around 14's IIRC).
I'm a bit apprehensive to have someone with maxed out INT & Edu among some more normally educated Investigators, espechly when those skills are Humanities heavy (History, Archeology, Latin & Greek), I don't want one character to be an "Oracle" from the get go, the character dose have many strings to his bow (as planed), but they are all in the Academics. I don't want him to only be useful for his academic skills and feel he has to only keep developing them since they are clearly his stitch and he may be reluctant to branch out.
the P.I. has a range of Combat & Investigation Skills, as well as some social, the Dilettante apart from bring Social Skill, Cash & Contacts to the table also has a grab bag of "Adventurer" type skills (mostly at low levels), the Journalist has some more social skills & Investigation skills as well as contacts. I don't want the academic to only see themselves useful for his academic skills and feel he has to only keep developing them since they are clearly his stitch and he may be reluctant to branch out. I think if I prune the Edu and Skill Pool back I may be able to encourage the player to develop a more eclectic skill base.
so far the academics player is awe struck with the awesomeness of a "Perfect" Edu roll, but would like to have his character closer to the age of the other characters (20-23) and is dithering on if he should reduce his Edu, for the next few weeks we are on tight time constraints on the scheduling of our CoC sessions and can't waste the time Um'ing & Aha'ing over finishing a character, but I don't want to force the issue as far as making an arbitrary call and risk tainting the character.
any guidance from Keepers that play a lot more CoC than I do, also player opinions and points of view are welcome.