Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by klecser

  1. One of the Investigator Handbook's main selling points is that it contains an information-rich gazetteer of the 1920s. Softcover version currently on sale if you're looking to save on retail! https://www.chaosium.com/call-of-cthulhu-investigator-handbook-7th-ed-softcover/
  2. Edit: Updated to switch PDF Links of above to physical product. Added PDF of 7th Edition Mansions of Madness Volume 1, since I explicitly mentioned the prior iteration as a solid intermediate scenario collection.
  3. I strive for immersion and authenticity whenever possible. My players are about to engage in more train travel between Boston and New York. I've tried in vain to find images of actual train schedules of the era. If it is close to 1923, that is fine, but getting the actual year just aides in the immersion. Alternatively, if anyone knows of specific CoC supplements that contain Boston/New York train schedules, that would work too. Help?
  4. What a spectacular surprise. Mansions of Madness is one of the most well-regarded classic scenario collections. It is one of my personal favorites. "Exploring the big house" is a primal attraction to CoC for a lot of people. And I like the idea of splitting it into two collections with lots of new material. Veterans get updates and something new. Bravo Chaosium. You sneaky sneaksters.
  5. My group just wrapped up a nine-session arc in the Dreamlands. We had a lot of fun. I ultimately decided I needed to move it back to the Waking World because I was running out of ideas that would keep is consistent with the wider campaign arc. I'm definitely looking forward to the new edition!
  6. Story-telling is inherently irrational. Any story demands whatever set of parameters are needed to affect us emotionally as people so we invest in it. I will never understand this modern trend of demanding rational from the irrational. The truth is that the story does whatever it needs to do in order to be fun. Now, you make a good point that different people find different things fun. I'm just concerned that this demand for rationality in story-telling is ultimately self-defeating, because there has never been an underlying expectation of rationality in human story-telling. Story was crafted by early humans to make them afraid of animals or situations that could kill them. They appealed to a bias toward primal instinct, not rationality. And our myths and legends have largely carried on this tradition. Now, as to your specific request, another question that could be asked is: To what extent are different stories within this "world" all happening at the same time, versus individual one-shots? It depends upon how you imagine it. It seems that you are imagining it as all stories exist, simultaneously. Another way to imagine it is that every story is an isolated incident. I'm thinking of the end of Clue where you get the "but it could have happened this way." To me, seeing someone obtain a tome in one story doesn't inherently mean that every other story in which a tome is discovered is happening concurrently. I view many of these stories as potentially isolated "what ifs." Whether Lovecraft intended it one way or the other doesn't really matter, in my opinion. It is up to each individual to interpret literature through their own lens. There are a lot of people who seem to think that people "must" consume Lovecraft in a certain way, and I find that perspective to be unfair. My perspective aside, I've really enjoyed reading your posts.
  7. Just wanted to point out we are now two years and four months since closure of a Kickstarter for a single scenario that was being "revised" and Sentinel Hill Press' response to criticism is "seek a refund." Classy.
  8. Makes perfect sense to me. I think you answered your own question. My advice to all Gamemasters, of all games, is always to trust yourself. If your players are hung up on whether or not you gave the wrong modifier to a firearms roll in low light conditions, you have bigger problems than your modifier choice. I'm willing to venture that most players are going to have an internal dialogue of "makes sense" and "this is a challenge to our goals!"
  9. Sorry, remember that I am a classroom teacher and the world is kinda topsy turvy and with a lot of intense reinvention right now. 😕
  10. This is my bad Bill. I had come to learn irreverent to mean "cheeky," but in looking up a variety of definitions, it's clear that it's main definition is much more closely aligned with "disrespectful." That is not what I meant. I meant cheeky. I was attempting to compliment Joerg's humor and I messed up. I'm sorry.
  11. I appreciate this hefty irreverence. Also, you can always use any of my comments.
  12. I'm really enjoying listening to Wind Words Ep. 2 today. I could listen to you guys muse all day long! -A fan
  13. The simple answer to your question is that the "right" answer is whatever is right for your game. You don't need our permission to be fair and creative. Your idea makes sense.
  14. Edit: Sorry, I missed MOB's pinned post above. I stand by my comments of congratulations below though! Check it out. Congrats to @Chris S for this second edition and thank you Chaosium @Rick Meints and @Mike M for supporting the expansion of a second edition!
  15. Counterpoint: I will take having to tie rather than getting a higher level of success in most circumstances.
  16. Hey BRP Forums, I know it might be difficult to think about recreation right now, but there may be an argument for needing exactly that to keep our SAN manageable. So, I hope you can get a positive feeling from this.
  17. @Rick Meints @Mike M @MOB This has gotta suck for Chaosium. Thank you for fixing the issue, and I hope that you didn't have to take a financial hit on the reprints.
  18. I would be surprised if copies were reprinted that quickly.
  19. I am definitely interested but I am on a personal moratorium on CoC Kickstarters right now until a majority of my existing ones are delivered. If and when that might be.
  20. As a new player to ASL, I've been very frustrated that Starter Set 1 is not available. I have Starters 2 and 3, which is a good place to get me started, but Box Set 1 is sold out and it includes some good maps with basic scenarios. I recognize that I could pick some of this up via PDF or buying some maps separately (many are sold out). In positive news, a buddy of mine was in town and we got a game in and it was a blast. Starter 2 is a fairly economical place to start, if you are interested @Bill the barbarian. As far as learning the game, this YouTube series helped me the most: I've also found that watching game play on YouTube has not been helpful because rarely are they teaching games. It is veterans playing the game at the speed of light and it might as well be in a different language.I'm really missing context on WHY the rules are designed a certain way. I learn games best when I understand the "whys" of the mechanics. ASL is a very intimidating game to get into, but when I actually sat down and played, it was fun. But I had to concentrate tremendously because we were basically teaching ourselves with no guidance, so after playing for two hours I was exhausted. "Why not locate veterans in your community?" Because I don't like playing games with people I don't know. Gaming needs to be an energizing thing for me, not energy sucking, and playing with randoms in my community is energy sucking 95% of the time. So, do check it out. It is an awesome game. It just has a really really steep learning curve.
  • Create New...