Jump to content

Scotty

Administrators
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    1,510

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    17

 Content Type 

Posts posted by Scotty

    RuneQuest Rules Q&A

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    On 3/31/2024 at 8:17 AM, Gamesmeister said:

    Is the Find (substance) rune spell the same as the Command (species) rune spell in that you specify the substance (or species) up front when you acquire the spell?

    Yes, eg Find Gold, Find Truestone, Find Water

    On 3/31/2024 at 8:17 AM, Gamesmeister said:

    Or can you choose the substance each time you cast the spell?

    You can of course run it this way, but note the Rune varies depending on substance.

    • Like 1

    Disease confusion

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    15 hours ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    Hmmm, well for those that like to have some form of explainable logic so when they do weird stuff like I am and send players into the dead place we can make reasonable judgements on what happens.

    Gloranthan reality is defined by mythology, not by hard logic or physics. RQG, Magic and Mythology, page 8

    15 hours ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    Certainly my players think diseases are passed by disease spirits much as you say. 
    So I think the answer to my question is that in effect broo cannot pass on a disease in the dead place. Any disease spirit that is created to facilitate this, either cannot exist in the dead place, or if somehow it appears, it immediately turns to some form of gorp sludge….however chaos features do work in the dead place….so I could just play the “it’s chaos” and ignore all logic have disease infection still occur.

    You didn't mention the Dead Place in your initial post. In the Dead place, spirits become physical, so a broo acting as a spirit vortex would pop out a physical disease, or it's giant disease spirit would physically appear and bud off more smaller diseases, or any disease spirits hovering as a cloud would just precipitate out. I'd give them a SIZ & STR equal to their POW. In this environment I'm not sure they'd attack, and most would would likely wander off. Adventurers won't catch diseases.

    15 hours ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    Now however, if I follow that logic, my players may figure out that the ideal way to rid oneself of any possession spirit including disease spirits, is just enter the dead place.

    Yes. Although bear in mind the fine alkaline dust which hangs in the air, damaging lungs and burning skin. (RQG 124). Adventurers in my game would only travel there when raining as the dust was an hourly attack (POT = half max daily temperature) and daily vs metal armour. Travelling across alkali flats in the rain is miserable and your feet still need protecting. See Prax Temperature and Precipitation, RQG 122. Getting down into it is the biggest problem as the steep stream gullies are prone to flash flooding

    15 hours ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    Of course, they would also lose any bound spirits too,

    Yes, they'd appear physically and be released. They could be chased down, physically captured  and forcibly taken out, then rebound outside of the Dead Place.

    15 hours ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    unless they had a friendly shamen nearby, which is what happened to be the case in my game, to hold those spirits for them while they enter the place.

    Alternatively find the Father of Independants  and sacrifice for Dead Place Ferry (RBM 40).

    • Like 2

    RuneQuest Rules Q&A

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    28 minutes ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    Now Broo don’t carry multiple disease spirits so each wound they inflict passes on another spirit I believe. So in fact they are carrying an infection? I assume this is not a spirit?

    However it acts, treat the result as a disease spirit. 

    28 minutes ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    So….the key question is what form is the Broo disease that it carries?

    The broo is a disease carrier (per Carry (Disease) RQB 93 / RBM 24). It just carries the disease, with infection caused by a disease spirit. There's no explanation of how this actually works (as it's magic), but perhaps the broo acts a disease spirit vortex and its carved runes are a portal to the Middle World, or perhaps it carries a giant disease spirit that buds off smaller ones, or it attracts disease spirits that hover around it as a cloud and infect those it come into contact with...

    (added to Q&A)

    Disease confusion

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    28 minutes ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    Now Broo don’t carry multiple disease spirits so each wound they inflict passes on another spirit I believe. So in fact they are carrying an infection? I assume this is not a spirit?

    However it acts, treat the result as a disease spirit. 

    28 minutes ago, Geoff R Evil said:

    So….the key question is what form is the Broo disease that it carries?

    The broo is a disease carrier (per Carry (Disease) RQB 93 / RBM 24). It just carries the disease, with infection caused by a disease spirit. There's no explanation of how this actually works (as it's magic), but perhaps the broo acts a disease spirit vortex and its carved runes are a portal to the Middle World, or perhaps it carries a giant disease spirit that buds off smaller ones, or it attracts disease spirits that hover around it as a cloud and infect those it come into contact with...

    (added to Q&A)

    • Like 2

    RuneQuest Rules Q&A

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    36 minutes ago, PhilHibbs said:

    Oh! I thought that that was different to a skill with a 00 base like read/write or martial arts. I always thought that a modified skill of zero could be rolled at 5% chance and learn from experience. Is that wrong?

    No. You can certainly give it a go, the other question was about augmenting. I would not let players augment those rolls.

    36 minutes ago, PhilHibbs said:

    The only context in which the "until the skill rating is increased to above 0%" rule appears also says "Once the skill increases above 0%, the skills category modifier is applied", so the language heavily implies that this only applies to skills with a base chance of 00% and not to skills modified.

    Yes.

    RuneQuest Rules Q&A

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    On 3/15/2024 at 4:49 PM, Gamesmeister said:

    Couple of questions regarding skills

    If a skill is base chance 0%, we know category modifiers can't raise it above 0 until it's been trained or increased in some way.

    Yes

    On 3/15/2024 at 4:49 PM, Gamesmeister said:

    Does the same apply to augments i.e. can I apply a runic augment to a 0% skill to have a chance of success?

    No, you have to have a base above zero to add it to. 

    On 3/15/2024 at 4:49 PM, Gamesmeister said:

    Same question, but in this case a negative category modifier has reduced my chance of success to 0%. Can I augment it above 0% to give myself a chance to succeed?

    No, you have to have a base above zero to add it to.

    Don't forget that that if your base chance is 10% and your category bonus modifier is -15%, you are effectively at -5% which is read as 00%. To get your skill up to 1% you need to train/research 6% to reach +1% (-5+6=1%).

    If you managed to augment this, with for example +20%, it would be -5+20= 15%, rather than fiddle with numbers, just say no.

    As usual GMs are free to do want they want in their own games.

    • Like 1

    How does a Fetch get destroyed?

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    12 hours ago, shoggoth said:

    I don't understand that rule. As there are almost no way to reduce POW to zero, killing a fetch would never happen in practice.

    In a roleplaying game, never is usually more often than not. 

    12 hours ago, shoggoth said:

    So either this is a mistake in the RQ2 adaptation to RQG, and the correct rule would be to die at zero magic point not POW, or this is a correct rule that is intended to never apply. Don't know what to think.

    Zero magic points is unconsciousness. Note that a fetch reaching zero POW is very serious as it will kill the shaman too (A fetch is the awakened portion of the shaman’s soul).

    RuneQuest Rules Q&A

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    17 hours ago, Stephen L said:

    Cliff Toad Movement - p109 Bestiary:

    The Bestiary lists the Move of a Cliff Toad as:

        1/3 per D6 of SIZ (Hop) 

    This is very slow, a vast 9D6 toad would have a move of 3.

    Perhaps it should read:

        Walk 1, Hop 3 per D6 of SIZ

    It should read:

     1(3) per D6 of SIZ (Hop) 

    Reptile tail damage

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    5 hours ago, Alexandre said:

    Hits to arthropods legs and wings don't affect (too much) the total HPs or the functionalities of the creature. Shouldn't it be the same for the tail of reptiles? It can be rendered useless or even severed/maimed, but the creature shouldn't lose general HPs (maybe past the base hit points of the tail). What do you think? I thought this was the rule but actually I can't find it anywhere. 

    There are no specific rules that cover this. If you wish to change it in you games that's fine, although I wouldn't apply it to two-leggeds as they use their tail for balance. I'd suggest that they don't bleed to death if they drop their tail - it's a defence mechanism - and then they play dead.

    Shaman-Priests in RuneQuest

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    2 hours ago, ajs said:

    Checked main rules and Cults book for both Daka Fal and Waha with respect to tithes to temple for a priest/shaman

    They are cult shaman-priests that likely are running the temple, any income goes to their temple (them). They manage it on behalf of the cult and all the other income. It's the same for issaries priest who are basically the temple.

    2 hours ago, ajs said:

    Doesn't feel right that they give up 90% of their income as they're no temples to support just them

    Anything they need, comes from their tithe. Eg, their noble standard of living is paid from that.

    2 hours ago, ajs said:

    The specific PC is playing an Earth Wicth whcih has a similar set up

    Earth witch is a spirit cult and unless affiliated with an an Ernalda temple would be independant. Independant shaman have no cult tithing (no cult) and must support themselves. Rather than getting into a running a shop game, a shaman has an income of 30L (Poor SoL) and uses their Spirit Combat or Spirit Travel as occupational income skills.

    A cult shaman will likely use a noble income.

    • Like 5
    • Thanks 2

    Detect and Find spells - confusing

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    1 hour ago, mfbrandi said:

    So you have to remember to turn around and look behind you, to take off your backpack and look at it, and so on? Hmm …

    No. As I said The GM says "over there in a house you see a faintly glowing sword", for above "and behind you you see a magic crystal in a pouch on the guard". The spell description says

    1 hour ago, mfbrandi said:

    I take it the thing sought doesn’t really glow. It is more like a head-up display or AR headset — the effect is “painted on” at the caster’s end. This is just my guess, of course.

    It glows for the caster.

    Quote

    This spell informs the caster of the presence of the substance sought by giving it a slight identifying glow (or similar effect for non-visual senses) that is visible only to the caster.

    RBM 52

     

    • Like 1

    Detect and Find spells - confusing

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    17 hours ago, Rodney Dangerduck said:

    Find XXX, p328-329, does not have a Find Magic, but we know that the pregen Sorala has a Find Magic matrix

    It's a good example of a unique heirloom. It is a Dragonewt figurine - so who knows its origin.

    17 hours ago, Rodney Dangerduck said:
    1. How come Magic is now a substance?

    If you don't want it to be so, disallow it in your games, or make it a special Lhankor Mhy magic, or change the magic.

    17 hours ago, Rodney Dangerduck said:
    1. The caster is "informed" and "aware" of the item.  How?  A rough direction and distance?  If so, why not say that?

    It glows, so the range is effectively sight. If a magic sword was in a house the caster could see the sword in the house. The GM says "over there in a house you see a faintly glowing sword". If the sword was 4m under the earth, the spell could not penetrate that deep (note that there are some specialist spells that ignore the 3m rule).

    17 hours ago, Rodney Dangerduck said:
    1. There is also a "slight identifying glow", just for the caster.  Is this the answer to #2?

    Yes

    17 hours ago, Rodney Dangerduck said:
    1. If the identifying glow is so "slight", how come it takes 3 freaking meters of stone to block it?  How about a dark cloth wrapping or a wooden box?

    The spell is blocked not the glow. The sword would still glow if in a dark cloth wrapping or a wooden box, but it wouldn't glow 4m under the earth.

    Humakti "double damage" v weapons

    in RuneQuest

    Posted

    On 2/21/2024 at 8:56 AM, PhilHibbs said:

    Should a blessed parrying weapon do extra damage?

    Yes. 

    On 2/21/2024 at 8:56 AM, PhilHibbs said:

    What if you specifically attack their weapon to destroy it?

    Yes

    On 2/21/2024 at 8:56 AM, PhilHibbs said:

    Is that a "Non-Humakti" thing to do,

    No, as long as the fight honorable (LB 108).

    On 2/21/2024 at 8:56 AM, PhilHibbs said:

    and does it make a difference if the wielder is illuminated?

    No.

×
×
  • Create New...