Rust asked me to give my impression of the system (where future campaigns are concerned) after I got a chance to browse, so here I go.
First, I'll say up front my time with my new book has been limited. I've had a busy week so far and it's just starting!
I started the thread asking about some specific items, so I'll address my biggest concerns.
1: Equipment:
The weapon selection gave me a really good starting point. I may have to tweak here and there but for the most part, sehr gut.
The armor I can pretty much leave alone except to delete an itel or two. No force fields for me although I really like how they represented that armor choice.
No Mecha or Robot rules at all, though there was a single mecha example. My mecha will be limited to powered armor and robots will be basic but it would have been nice to see just a bit of a build process.
Where equipment really falls down is in the general area. What benefit for having or penalty for not having a first aid kit, surgery kit, or other kits? The computer description was decent and the autodoc was right on the money but other kits will need some work.
2: Skills: Excellent. I don't think I'll have to do much of anything here.
3: Starships: Non existent I could use the provided vehicle chase rules except that handling (a very important vehicle characteristic) seems to have been left undefined. The build system and combat damage, I can get by without as I've pratically built a simple one already.
Could someone tell me if I missed the definition of handling and how it's applied? I ran through the book pretty quickly so I may have missed it.
3: Aliens: I think a bit more effort might have been put into this subject.It's maybe the easiest to get by without (I can just steal more mundane monsters if needs must).
My biggest complaint? Wealth. I can't tell you how much I despise wealth systems. I know it's a pain because of the many genres that have to be represented but specifying X units would have made it much less work. Don't define units and put in a blurb saying stuff from outside a tech level would cost more (or less in some cases) than stuff in the represented genre.
So, I'm happy to say I won't have to do much work on skills at all. THAT would have been work. Weapons are pretty much where I need them to be thought he other equipment is going to require effort.
Starships and vehicular combat will need some details roughed out as well.
It may sound like I'm not happy but I am. I'd give this a 3.5/5 and I would expect it to improve greatly by the time it hits the printers.
My suggestions to Chaosium:
Dump wealth.
Flesh out the technology for each genre, if only a little.
Scales of combat could be easily done by multiplying vehicle heavy weapon damage (and AP/HP) by five and REALLY big weapons (waterborne ships, starships, and some aircraft) by 10.
Define the vehicle rules. Chases happen in all time periods so this is an important feature to have working.
Spend just a little time on Aliens.
All in all, I think it has amazing potential. I'd be happy to wait months to get the bugs worked out and I'd pay 150% of what I paid already for the right product.
Thanks Chaosium!