Kloster

True, it's a risk. Runequestement votre, Kloster

This is exactly what I would not buy. I would be interested in either a realistic western setting, or in a version that allows to represent one of the categories of western movies (spaghetti, gritty, classical,...), but not a supernatural western. Perhaps I'm too old for the mainstream tastes. Runequestement votre, Kloster

It's easy to disrupt and strike in the same round. Runequestement votre, Kloster

Of course it is feasible. I just told that parrying with your attack weapon means removing it from it's direction, and is slower than dodging or parrying with another weapon, wether dagger, main gauche, shield, lantern or cape. If most duels in the 3 musketeers period were done with 2 weapons is not a random fact. Runequestement votre, Kloster

This is exactly my point. With the MWT, this is random. With the hit locations, player choose to remain or not (if they are not disabled). If they die, this is their choice to have taken the risk (barring the disabling or killing blows). I never complained about BRP being lethal, I like that. But I like to be able to choose my strategies. I can choose to be heroic and having a high chance to die, or backing out and play safer. What I don't like is the random extra lethality, especially (as noted) when coupled with random armor. Runequestement votre, Kloster

The ability to kill with one hit in real life is also fairly low. So, BRP lethality pleases me. But if the setting don't require it, I don't wan't EXTRA lethality. And I agree, there are deadlier games. Some settings required it (cyberpunk for instance). Runequestement votre, Kloster

Agreed. Also agreed. QUOTE=Enpeze;4590] ... You are more into the classical literatic "hero" and cinematic thing than me I assume.

In that case (long jump), it is as much a limitation of innate capabilities than one of training and dedication. Runequestement votre, Kloster

I know it is realistic, and I agree with your comments. This is tactics I employ even without the Major wound table. But RPG are GAMES and should be enjoyable. That does not mean I don't want PC to be immortal, but I think BRP is deadly enough, and the extra lethality brought in by the MWT and Variable armor unnecessary. It is in line with setting with SB, so should be used, but I would not use it for the other BRP incarnations. RQ and CoC are deadly enough. Runequestement votre, Kloster

Aces and Eights seems beautiful and overly complicated, and appears as out of stock for all the european distributors I have checked. Runequestement votre, Kloster

For me, it's not the only real one, but this is truly a big problem. Hit location permits a different protection value on the different locations (as a flak jacket that don't protect arms). Another one is that it forbids certain tactics (aiming to strike a certain location to disarm, or to hit more vital area). The biggest problems I have with the major wound table (I'm speaking of the one of SB1, because this is the only one I have used) is that it is completely random. It may be desirable in SB, where the chaos is the driving force, but I don't think it can be desirable in other settings. Besides that, the wounds caused by a broadsword and a firearm are completely different, and require a different table (I don't see how you can cut the nose of your opponent with a colt peacemaker). If we have several table depending on the weapon, it becomes more complicated than managing the hit locations, and if we don't, the wounds can be aberrant. And I'm not even speaking of the lethality of the combination of Major wound table / Variable armor. I don't care loosing a character because I'm beaten by a superior foe or because I'm doing mistakes, but I don't like to see the death or the unusability of a character just because of sheer bad luck on 2 consecutive dice rolls. Runequestement votre, Kloster

As I have a quite severe allergy to D20, I don't check what is displayed in the few gamestores I visit. It's so not a surprise I've never heard of it. For the others, I have to check. It can be interesting. There are also a few french language produced amateur games (10000$ Reward, Western Parade). Runequestement votre, Kloster

You were faster than I am on this one. I perfectly agree. Runequestement votre, Kloster

I just found it, top of the thread list. >:-> Runequestement votre, Kloster

They are allowed to cast spells. Allied spirits are even initiates of the cult, so have access to one use runic magic. The problem for this tactic is the perception of the target. Familiars (at least animal based ones) can see, so no problemo. Allied spirits bind to animals (an alynx for Orlanth forex) are in the same position. A Humakt allied spirit bind in a sword has no eye, so will need a spell to be able to target the following combat or healing spells (soul sight, second sight, mystic vision are the one that comes to mind). A fetch is discorporate, so I don't know. Runequestement votre, Kloster

Hi, As a sidetrack of this thread (http://basicroleplaying.com/forum/basic-roleplaying/263-ancient-history-3.html) what do you think of a western setting for BRP? Would it be playable or too deadly? Would it be interesting? Except for deadlands, I haven't seen a Western RPG for long. The ones that comes to mind for me are Boot Hill (TSR), Western Hero (Hero Games) and Wild West (FGU) and they are old quite ancient. Runequestement votre, Kloster

I agree. That's why I told it's better to do it on someone who is trying to heal (already wounded and the chance on failing INT roll) than on somebody else. The chance is low but the gain is higher on those targets. Runequestement votre, Kloster

I think it's me. Runequestement votre, Kloster

You're doing a fine job, Triff. Runequestement votre, Kloster

IIRC, the cretan bow is a U shaped, simple composite bow, made with wood, reinforced with bones and sinew. The scythian one was a recurved composite bow. But for atlanteans, both are OK. Runequestement votre, Kloster

Hello Jason, Do you know if foreign version are planned? Runequestement votre, Kloster

I think you are underestimating it. As you tell, it is very important during "complex interactions of archery and spellcasting", but those interactions are not rare. And it does not affect only the 1st round, because actions that carry over from 1 round to the other one replace the action of the new round. Runequestement votre, Kloster

Not by much, RQ rule was that you add your category mod to the roll before comparing to the value. Runequestement votre, Kloster

Hello Jason, Is the optional location table unique or separated in a melee and a missile one? Runequestement votre, Kloster

Historically, at least for french and german language, the Grenadier was the soldier throwing grenades, so HE was the grenade launcher!!! Runequestement votre, Kloster