scott-martin

Top post of the season. Those dots are thrilling in themselves. Has this scenario design methodology ever been published??

Definitely. If you have Dark Earth, you're on the non Fertile side and don't necessarily pass on your crown from mother to daughter but from auntie to niece . . . Asrelia and TKT are sisters, one lucky and one not, Ernalda and Maran are sisters of binary aspect, Babeester and Voria are sisters. Running through this thread is the notion that Aldryami and Mostali are also Earth Tribe peoples only estranged from human history.

Love the reference to the Wall. IMG unregulated worship of anyone below II-25 is "unlawful" if not actively wicked by Dara Happan standards so would make a great outlaw religion depending on how nasty you want the character to be and the nature of his specific grievance. In my experience there isn't a lot of room for theology in these lifestyles but they collect a lot of spirit magic. Another vote for a Lodrilite with points sacrificed to Monster Man here, by the way.

This is one of the spells I'd love to see RQG integrate more closely into the Passions mechanics. It's a whole lot easier to simply scan all character sheets in range and return all relevant Hates . . . personal, situational / transactional (a potentially rich area of the rules), cult / homeland. Basically a way to weaponize ye olde Cult Compatibility Table. My suspicion is that if Illumination can fool Sense Chaos it also blanks binary "yes/no" empathy magic. Fortunately Mindspeech /Mind Link is off the books.

I hear you here. "Somebody bit us / uz bad and now us / uz busted (buzted)" works for everyone whose babies don't thrive in this awful place. For me right now the uzko are the people of the curse. Like the Bestiary says, "enlo are found wherever dark trolls are found." Maybe other Dark/Man lineages that were extant at the time received another affliction and tell their own blasted womb stories. As you point out, the muri situation is unusual. I've always thought her first wound was the curse and the second was embracing Heat in order to become something other than uzko. The Tarmo trolls rejected this solution and remained uzko, complete with enlo. For all I know cave, sea and mountain trolls discovered their own solutions and became what they are now. There might be a fossil record of mixed enlo/uzko burials dating back to the Storm Age, in which case Nysalor isn't really the problem but a kind of catalyst activating a latent propensity for weak babies. When my fantasy OOO missionaries came, they reminded a lot of Dark/Man and Shadow/Man entities about the KL gospel, "how to be a troll" and why Nysalor is a name to hate. But beyond Tarmo, I can't think of an enlo-producing community that wouldn't have already been engaged in the Broken Council schism and so wouldn't have known the Curse first hand. Maybe Borklak or Chen Durel, although I sometimes wonder if the Chen Durel trolls in particular weren't the digijelm who made Dara Happans fear the night. But then, I don't really know if Borklak survives long enough to even be eligible for the curse. Halikiv was involved. Dagori Inkarth and the Shadow Plateau and their satellites were involved. The Elder Wilds were probably represented. I guess Xarkarsh and the Blue Moon were involved? Who else gets enlo? We do know that there were trolls once in Chen Durel and now the place is a mass of enlo. My heretical dream hypothesis is that these "enlo" are what we would call people, homo sapiens, cousins of the "dark men" who conveniently emerged in Peloria when the local trolls were expunged. Oppressed, stunted, horribly abused and equally badly educated, but cut one open and you won't find a rock gizzard or any other extra organs. After all, the smallest enlo are small, just SIZ 7. The biggest enlo are bigger than human, SIZ 12. Most average 9-10, slightly malnourished and weak by Genertelan standards. About as cunning as a human if you factor for the lack of intellectual training. The POW is terrible but what else can you expect? I blame their society. The Kralorelans have their own theories about dark hsun chen, etc.

Hon-Eel loved exploiting reciprocal "earth mother" initiation wherever she could find it. If enough lightning (or whatever the right omen might be) will "convince the examiners" that you're one of them, infiltration is trivial.

I always looked at it backward. Dark People who participated in Black Eater received the Curse and are what we now call "trolls." The line is much blurrier as you move away from Dagori Inkarth and Halikiv culturally as well as geographically. People who weren't at Black Eater in this scenario don't get enlo so don't tell a story. For me it raises the question of whether Chen Durel participated in Black Eater or if not, where all those true-breeding SIZ 9-10 "enlo" come from . . . which might or might not be your question since this could be a separate phenomenon. Also I hear rumors of an uzko presence in Umathela supporting a large "enlo" population there but haven't seen the specific reference lately. If so, are these uzko original invaders from wonderhome or surface migrants from elsewhere? (Black Ships again.) In the latter scenario they would've brought the curse and its theodicy with them.

Love this most of all.

They still had a concentration of badass magicians on the island then. Maybe not enough to completely defy the blue man and his people, but enough to skirt his curse just that once. Which raises the hypothesis that the effect mutated over time under the weight of generations of relentless and increasingly desperate magical countermeasures. The rump God Learners had a century between the tsunami and their doom to throw everything they had at it. While they clearly failed to roll it back entirely, their combined work might well have fragmented the effect, inviting new catastrophes in some times and places while softening others. Either way, the initial phases seemed surprisingly gentle, sending boats back from Brithos or all the way back to the docks depending on their orientation to the "closing wave" or "wall." Maybe you get smashed only if you take too aggressive a tack against what would then amount to a true doom current . . . when your propulsion magic is too strong to fight the standing repulsion, the timbers pop. Our sense of whether the Closing has changed over the publishing history is probably closely connected. A casual search indicates an ambiguous reference in Griffin Mountain . . . while "the oceans were cursed" the only real impact described is "all surface traffic was swept away." Spirits of the Sea in WF 8 is the only previous extended reference I've found so far and focuses on what happened to surviving waertag enclaves. I wonder how much Closing Lore comes from contacts with beached waertagites and how reliable it is. I don't even know for sure how we have such clarity on exactly when Jrustela ruptured.

Arrrrrgan Arrrrrgarrrrr. Breakin' rocks in the . . . hot sun! I fought the [devil] and . . . we won.

Since Troll Gods has been open today I was struck by the little decorative ornaments in the layout. They always worked really well for me to convey a sense of an elder underworld culture's expression of the sacred: archaic, inscrutable, maybe a little brutal. Alien: This time around I know exactly where I've seen them before. They're Clark Ashton Smith rock carvings: How great is that? My guess is that somebody had a copy of The Fantastic Art of Clark Ashton Smith around and ran off a few stencils. Since I only have the Avalon Hill box I can't say if they showed up then (how wild would it be if they were a Dobyski idea) or (more likely) were inherited from the Chaosium side. What's especially exciting is that there's a lot more of this stuff extant so if you like this vision of gnawed troll fetishes, treat yourself. And then there's this character, who I haven't been able to track back to a klarkashtonian source yet and may actually be original:

I think you've got all the facts. Where this has taken me at least is trying to figure out what the broos were like when they were just another tribe of beast and who would develop magic to interfere with Hykimite gifts. Once upon a time at least a few of the chaos array were Bright Empire gods who fell in the wars were revealed to have always already been evil. I usually consider broos as awful as far back as anyone can remember but now I'm wondering where and when a nation failed the sex pit. EWF was interested in engineering the beast rune too . . . an innocent observer would see the Dorastor cover as another idyllic satyr picnic and yet the Wild Temple rite gets pretty bloody, just like the Serpent Beasts are noted for their "cruelty." I also wonder at the Praxites as a multi-totemic society apparently bereft of draconic tutelage. Herbivore riders as opposed to carnivore lycanthropes. Is that the difference? But if anyone remembers the Serpent Beasts, it's the Elk Riders. It's not hard to envision a scenario where the expanding Malkionite civilization pushed various sylvan neighbors to opt for "cruelty," effectively corrupting everyone around them. They have a whole technique for evoking the worst in everyone they meet. Solve et vincere. They got better and better at making monsters, eventually ensuring that every time they met dragons it was fearsome.

Could practically be a quiet moment at the Wild Temple. While I wouldn't plan any picnics with them either way (people drink too much and get crazy) a close look reveals at least four beasts present, including what might be one of the Damalite people who formerly ranged southern Peloria. He's probably a beast collector, has his own flesh zoo.

And the forests will echo with something! Does anybody remember "something?"

Yeah, I'm pretty mouthy today. I just cleared a month of PowerPoint and got four hours sleep. So while trying to see how far down the coast noted Blue Moon expert (and possible knowledge saboteur) Thorloss the Scribe could've gotten in the early 850s I'm reminded of the 842 invasion of Esrolia, still a troll protectorate within the larger EWF complex. The annotation in MSE is interesting in a larger Malkionite mytho-historical context: The dragons can muster the help of all the krjalki races. Some speculate that those are actually creations of the dragons . . . when pressed, the dragons can muster members of every nonhuman race to their armies, even Aldryami (who have an unbroken history of friendship with us in the West). Now the children of Malkion have fought at least one dragon empire before, whether you consider the Hykimites and the Serpent Beasts as aspects of the same civilization or not. Back then the dragon people were the crown of "beast folk" creation, the kings of the forest keeping all the more profane totemic nations -- lion people, elk people, horse people, bull people, wolf people, bear people, elephant people, maybe eleven beasts in all and more -- in their proper shapes. You could speculate that all of the beast people are actually creations of the "dragons" and when pressed the "dragons" could probably muster members of every forest nation to their armies. This would be when the lore of dragon speaking and dragon slaying entered the Western way. Of course overt draconic influences are extremely rare there now. They've been largely exterminated and their orphaned children converted into today's horals and dronars according to their lot in life. As the frontier pushed east and eastern missionaries pushed back they met new dragons and more exotic krjalks. The pattern was set. By the time the West gets to the Shadowlands they know how to deal with monsters. The question is how the Aldryami and the "dragons" diverged. Hrestol (there he is again) is busy with the children of likita and while there are elves in the forest also they're already aloof, almost as though they'd be happy if all the meat people could be manipulated into wiping each other out. Of course the "unbroken history" is a lie because the elves were some of the Bright Empire's strongest allies . . . along with the beast nations of course. Looking at the map Rist straddles Kartolin Pass in the dawn times, keeping the Hykimites and Serpent Beasts apart or at best managing their contacts. I'm no conspiracy buff but it's a shame that Rist was one of the forests that had to die. Think of what they knew and what secrets they took with them when the survivors withdrew back to Dorastor to brood on the end of the world. And Peloria is interesting because there aren't a whole lot of atavistic hsunchen or draconic influences left there either. Not a lot of elves for that matter, some digijem nations and a dwarf or two but short on krjalk. Were there once elders here and they just got absorbed into the human mob or drawn out into other people's wars? Can we bring them back, or is that just what the Chaos/Monster Empire is all about?

Even if he made it out there, he doesn't seem to have put the pieces together, citing only two known human cultures with significant Blue Moon contact. The Veldang were far away and everyone in the texts loves to remind themselves that the Loper People are extinct. Classic Greg tell. Once you take your eye off your enemy you are doomed. They were probably working in secret against the Empire all along. I wonder if Locsil acknowledged Moon as a Core Rune let alone Blue Moon. She bends just enough of the standard taxonomy that she might not have registered on even a specialist visiting ethnographer's radar, omnipresent but always invisible.

I keep coming back to the "tide-wracked" nature of the Holy Country. If there were uncharted Blue Moon contacts left in Genertela you would think they would be concentrated here . . . but Thorloss comes from Jadnor and doesn't see any of it. He may be foolhardy if not lying. If any Blue Magic did wash up on the beaches of Slontos a "troll civil war" may have been fought on multiple fronts.

It's almost easier to recalculate the chronology than it is to force someone so prestigious (and probably caste-bound in more ways than one) to take Jrustelan transport but the Svagad Fleet was evidently good enough. The Triosos wave is probably more of a problem in a post-waertagite environment but they might be a deliberate sacrifice coming in from the island to consolidate "the alliance" as the sorcerers become dominant and history repeats. They suffered our wooden boats in order to achieve the greater mission. I would love a Dormal's Journeys at some point to go with those Unfinished Tales editions. EDIT of course in my deepest fantasy he's looking for Brithos in order to assassinate the blue man and liberate the peoples. But when he gets there it's all just these tragic huts, reds and browns in squalor. And he realizes Time has already had its revenge on the sorcerers, there's nothing more he can do. So he teaches the natives how to sail.

Thanks all. Over and above the self parody aspect of wondering whether these really are Argan Argar maps (in which case I need to pay the Chain Gang a black nickel to maintain my subscription) the paracanonical nature of the Black Fleet does open up angles on the Shadowlands that might otherwise be lost or suppressed in the Belintar histories. For me one of the most interesting is the western thrust. As the Empire crumpled on that front, OOO was apparently either happy or as promulgator of IFWW ritually obligated to absorb desolate populations out that way. As we know that coast is still a mess. Maybe early Shadowlands outreach contributed to that mess, manipulating pig people populations (the troll wars of Dragon Pass as proxy between Argan and Aram?), raising or wrecking weird cities and so on. And of course if there were useful opportunities to loot / suppress occult secrets, OOO wouldn't mind a chance to clean up around Zistor. Many of these would probably be "Pelaskite" sites and so play into the tension there. Does he need ships to do that? Does their timeline respect the modern Closing dates? (Is a century or two missing from some archaic calendars and a lot of our hobby year dates are wrong? Don't shudder.) It's also always nice when we can find room for a neglected culture in the niches of the historical maps. I love what's happening with Teshnos. Here's textual evidence for the Shadowlands engaging with its neighbors. Also selfishly the northern expansion is interesting because it fills the narrative hole in the 1042 coup left as the Blue Moon recedes from the canonical stage. (As is her nature.) OOO can step up and play the troll role closer to home. Finally the estrangement of Pamaltelan trolls has always nibbled on me. I get that all kinds of people took all kinds of tunnels up to the surface and ended up in all kinds of situations. But Within Time there are clear efforts from someone to routinize "troll gods" into a somewhat cohesive system. This person might have been a God Learner with deep dark contacts. Might be Arkat or one of his sisters. Might be OOO because that's his thing. Either way, to bring the Moorgarki / Qualyarni complex into the KL framework requires a way to reach the southern continent. Could be imperial boats and then the texts get redistributed. Could be black boats on OOO's personal imprimatur. And since Robber is the mythic patroness of sailor trolls (maybe distinct from sea trolls, who can say) and also the mother of one of the premier naval war gods of the Empire, maybe the deep truth of how OOO and GL interacted is both simpler and more complicated. Guy just kept saying he wanted to get along.

Dazzling fore and aft but this bit triggers a Recognition that's been emerging throughout the thread thanks to the 6A material, etc. In a planetary environment "little suns" behave a lot like "storms" wandering freely and struggling for a place in the sky's lower reaches. As we know one of the siblings is enthroned, some are subjugated, others exiled, a few killed. "Umath" is another child of the sun from a different mother. Call him a "little sun" too or call him a storm. He aims high and is brought low. One of the "little sun" peoples develops a little differently in his memory shadow. Maybe they were raised in isolation, unconnected with their cousins until later. This has all happened and the copper records, being flat circles, imply that it will all happen again. The Dayzatar cult remembers and is gently elevated to irrelevance, leaving dirty buserians behind. Lodril is more complicated. Weird vestiges persist on the fringes, places like Pent where archaic sun and storm are still at war, the vestigial elemental cults of Ignorance, whatever they had in "Umath"ela before their mythology was combed out. Put an umath back together, find a lost city (did he ever have a city or just need one of his own when there weren't enough), be a lost tribe, raise a planet.

Looking at it all with a strategic eye (guten abend Max) I start to suspect that the Hrestol Saga we have is actually a propaganda document of the Saval faction. Whether the Saints ever went to that island and did those things in that way in their mortal lifetimes is less important than the story of how autonomous sorcery overreached. Whether all the archaic documents can be placed with Gloranthan ownership (probably in those dreary centuries of schism and reconstruction) remains a work in progress.

Only Old One, not a complicated lacanian pun on the AAA, although it might have been one accidentally.

Fun jokes notwithstanding, pondering whether the Argan Argar Atlas might be a Gloranthan document that reflects the sum total of the Chain Gang's knowledge of the surface world makes me think back to the obscure "frightening armada of pitch-black ships crewed entirely by trolls" the OOO was once said to have launched to consolidate his post-EWF empire. Presumably the archaic troll maritime tradition (Robber being a darkness entity, after all) remains intact but their continued absence from the Ship Types list reveals that they don't sail much any more. Their original design might've been the ancestor of the modern Kethaelan trireme -- I'm sure experts have already weighed in. Is there still room for troll navies Since Time? When did they sail and where did they go? (Was the OOO a party to the conspiracy against EWF and received the protectorate over the north and west as his reward?) Did they (re)establish communication with the Pamaltelan cousins? Where do sea trolls come from? They're apparently omnipresent in the East Isles and Jrustela if the Bestiary can be believed.

I love it. If only more people could expect any form of accountability at all from that one! From the scattered notes on Dormal's logs we have, his larger mission was at least compatible with piecing together the tale of the doomed Empire: old ruins, new cities, new coasts. I wouldn't be surprised if much of what we have now (maybe even the MSE manuscript) derives from his travelogue. If people are looking for a Gloranthan bestseller this is probably one, unless of course it remains a Holy Country state secret instead. That would be a tale to tell after the nominal end of the waertagites. Of course they wouldn't tell it to me, especially if it involved them riding profane wooden boats like everyone else.

Navigationalism is its own faith with Abiding dispensation but the official rokarite position seems to be in flux . . . before 1618 Guilmarn felt comfortable enough with the rite to support at least a small navy without fretting too much about offending Leplain. In the very near future they'll have more traditional maritime partners and the League is in trouble. I doubt the people of Arolanit have traveled by sea in 900 years. All of this does beg the question of what Dormal was hoping to gain in finding Brithos.