Thaz

Which is why some friendly god taught Trollkin about spears.

Nope. That's been corrected and clarified

Should be fairly rare. I mean most people are not going to use a crushing weapon with negative dam bonus unless it's in extremis or improvised. However at that point I'd rule the negative dam bonus went to minimum loss so the crit does the max possible damage for that person. So shall we say they're doing 1d10+2 Weapon "plus" -1d6 dam bonus I would rule :- 10+2-2 = 10 and ignores armour. Just IMHO of course.

It really is. Certainly as BwT have been playing it as otherwise stacking various spells for years in sequence becomes rather easy. Sure Shield and Axe Trance dont let you lead normal lives. But Charisma and various other spells do. Of course that may well be worth it in some cases but that's a nice crunchy set of choices for players and I'm all in favour of options. Sure you can stack x but it's going to mean you have no or limited rune pool for the duration. Oh, your comrade is down and really needs a Heal Wound? Shame.

Squuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuueeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee <ahem> for a any number of reasons. Not least I plan on running a bunch of players through online games soon. Plus another reason or two.

Critical impale (page 203) - twice the maximum damage plus roll damage bonus (plus magic damage bonus if any). Weapon is stuck in body. Critical slash (page 204) - twice maximum damage plus roll damage bonus (plus magic damage bonus if any) Critical crush (page 206) - Maximum weapon damage plus maximum damage bonus twice (plus magic damage bonus if any) AND Special Crush (page 206) rolled weapon damage plus rolled Damage Bonus plus Maximum Damage Bonus. Critical Crush (page 206) Maximum weapon damage plus twice Maximum Damage Bonus, ignores armour.

Reading the entire thread is indeed confusing. However having done so it's pretty clear. You could perhaps read it as a new ruling on the rules. Scotty and Jason have stated what it is. I get that there is a desire for a grand design mech that explains it all, but there isnt. There's a very clear statement of both what a Impale, Slash and Crush crit means and seperately what a Crush special and crit look like. I can re quote them if you are browsing on a small screen and have trouble seeing them?

No. It's very very clear. Rule against it in your game all you want. YGMV

YGMV but that is not the ruling

"If a critical crush is rolled it does the maximum crushing damage, which is twice the maximum damage bonus plus the maximum weapon damage." Thats quote.

Ask Starbrow that question....

Given RQG is a higher power level to start and people have been playing a year or so now :- Go for it I say. Frankly we're going to need some bad bad dudes shortly.

I have 2 physical and 2 pdf different editions of it 😄 And thats AFTER I sold off my rq2 and duplicate collection.....

Moon Design is pretty much the Definitive Edition.

Maybe consider online? There's a fair few pick up games of RQG online

I've said a few times if I was starting over with RQG I would be tempted to start at Griffin Mountain. Possibly as a prequel to the forthcoming Sartar Campaign Jeff and co are working on. Right now my players are sat around Apple lane and its Dark of 1626. Pretty soon I have a lot of significant events happening and I'm not sure what to do about that. My Co-GM has nabbed the Prax option and I was going to peal left to Grazelands and now I know there's a Grazelands book coming also.....

I want to say the Iron Lords who turned out to be some very funky Mostali ...which may have been in GM actualy.

Quite the reverse. New Group/Campaign (1610 but using RQG) in addtion to the 2 RQG 1626 and 1 Witcher TTRPG I already play in. Only the Witcher game runs face-face so I guess that might get impacted later. We're good so far. On the negative side my monthly Hit-People-With-Chunks-of-metal practise got cancelled.

There were also some addons published in WD for GI back when GW put out the UK addition. Which were rather good iirc.

That's its entire purpose. Its official I belive

Ahem https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/194759/Shadowrun-Anarchy On Sale as well (well for today)

No. You just published an entire book detailing whats out there 😉

Coooooooooooooooool Beans. I cant quite recall if there's a copy in my vault of the previous edition. I'm not Rick Meints but I do have to use a spreadsheet to keep track of my RQ library.

Mr Harlech Quinn was pretty gosh darn cool. I do miss my shadowrun collection but it had got ridiculous.

Is this PDF or print as well? Looks Amazing.