Joerg Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 (edited) Rewriting the Vingkotling history surely is getting way off-topic here. I suggest each of us prepares a position paper and presents it in a separate thread. Right now there are more wild theories floating about than I am willing to handle. Otherwise, the exchange is going to look like more of this: 2 hours ago, metcalph said: Has it ever occurred to you that the so-called daughters of Vingkot might be mere names backlformed by skalds from the Tribal Names to create a spurious connection to Vingkot? Has it ever occurred to you that both the Entekosiad and the Glorious ReAscent of Yelm aren't any better than the tribal myths of the first Heortling tribes? Plentonius is a master of conjecture who has little more written sources than inscriptions of imperial names in masonry. Murharzarm is an invention of his, and Antirius is an invention of that street sweeper Avivath who sunspeared horse emperors with the power of Hastatus. The identification of the underworld star Tolat as a son of Yelm is an invention of his, replacing the green planet of Alkor. Plentonius has the Dawn in YS 11100, during the reign of Son of Evil, missing 100 years of History in his text. I might be able to cram a few more more or less flawed pet theories into this... Edited April 30, 2017 by Joerg Hastatus, not Sagittus. Has to be the more phallic version of the stick with pointy object on the tip. 2 Quote Telling how it is excessive verbis Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
soltakss Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 3 hours ago, Joerg said: I suggest each of us prepares a position paper and presents it in a separate thread. Right now there are more wild theories floating about than I am willing to handle. Prepare a paper? I thought this was just a game, not an academic exercise. Otherwise, the exchange is going to look like more of this: But it usually ends up like this, with two people picking each other posts aparts, refuting opinion with opinion. Has it ever occurred to you that both the Entekosiad and the Glorious ReAscent of Yelm aren't any better than the tribal myths of the first Heortling tribes? The Glorious ReAscent of Yelm is both historical and mythic, but I think is mostly useful. The Entekosiad, on the other hand, is deeply suspect. It seems to be a paper on a Lunar HeroQuestor's attempt to prove something and everything is coloured by that attempt. It is interesting and challenging, but I would not want to say that anything in it is factual. I am sure that a lot of it is, but many of the conclusions drawn are very iffy indeed. 1 Quote Simon Phipp - Caldmore Chameleon - Wallowing in my elitism since 1982. Many Systems, One Family. Just a fanboy. www.soltakss.com/index.html Jonstown Compendium author. Find my contributions here. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Oracle Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 5 hours ago, soltakss said: ... Prepare a paper? I thought this was just a game, not an academic exercise. ... In fact reading some of the discussions in these forums I'm not so sure about that ... ... but anyway in most cases I admire the knowledge of some of the veteran Glorantha sages. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jajagappa Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 30 minutes ago, Oracle said: In fact reading some of the discussions in these forums I'm not so sure about that ... ... Brings back the good old days of the Glorantha Digest! 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
metcalph Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 17 hours ago, Joerg said: Quote Has it ever occurred to you that the so-called daughters of Vingkot might be mere names backlformed by skalds from the Tribal Names to create a spurious connection to Vingkot? Has it ever occurred to you that both the Entekosiad and the Glorious ReAscent of Yelm aren't any better than the tribal myths of the first Heortling tribes? Um, yes as a matter of fact it has. In the post that you were responding to, I actually wrote: Quote As pointed out before Urvarinus has been attributed to two epic deeds that belong to somebody else (Brightface and Daxdarius). The myth of the Emperors of Dara Happa have been filtered through the unscrupulous hand of Plentonius. Likewise the Good People of Alkoth have a actual myth in which Murharzarm banishes the Heortlings to the south, the (Horse) Nomads to the east and the Carmanians to the west (and the anachronisms are not errors) All we can say is that in the Middle Storm Age the Dara Happans in their Septopoli peiod lost a city of Elempur to the Ram People, probably acting under the leadership of Varnaval. An Iron Ram was involved, possibly as a battering ram to break down the walls of Elempur. The Story of the making of the Army and the revenge exacted upon them has been attributed to Urvarinus. Unless we were to see a myth of about how the Sons of Vingkot brought an Iron Ram to battle in their fight against Dara Happa, we can not attribute the destruction of Elempur to them. It is my belief that all myths are of suspect historicity being warped by the attitudes and biases of their composers (Plentonius, Valare Addi, whoever composed the Vingkotling sagas etc) just as real world mythology is. There are many things they do not understand (When did Vingkot die? Who killed YarGan? Who is buried in the Jewelled Vault?) and the wrong answers they interpolate to explain these discrepancies are glaringly clear signs that the myths are dubious history at best. When the myths describe the events central to them (such as the raids of the Sons of Vingkot), they are at their strongest historically and at the same time, the discrepancies between them and the common understanding of that age are also the strongest (Where is Beren? Why do none of Vingkot's daughters appear?). Where the myths describe events that are ancillary to them (such as the description of Heort's ancestors in a myth about Heort's deeds), the material is filler and most closely harmonised to the orthodox wisdom not matter how erroneous that would be (Korol Kandoros is described as dying before Vingkot because the skald composing the mtyh thinks that Vingkot died fighting Wakboth at Stormfall which is well after Korol's death). Your problem IMO is that you accept the Orlanthi myths as being of equal truthfulness in described an ideal Orlanthi culture and warp foreign myths into such strange contortions (Jorganos sacked Elempur) to conform with them. Until you consider looking at the Orlanth in terms of, say, archeological change as Greg has done for Dara Happa and Pelanda, then your reconstructions will continue to be flawed. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ali the Helering Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 Soltakss said Prepare a paper? I thought this was just a game, not an academic exercise. I think you will find that the various games are in other sections (Runequest, Heroquest etc), whereas this is the Glorantha section, which is, when all is said and done, a continuation of Greg's anthropological academic exercise. 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
g33k Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 1 hour ago, Ali the Helering said: I think you will find that the various games are in other sections (Runequest, Heroquest etc), whereas this is the Glorantha section, which is, when all is said and done, a continuation of Greg's anthropological academic exercise. but ... ducks. You are refuted. By Humakti bearing the Truth rune, no less! Quote C'es ne pas un .sig Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jajagappa Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 4 hours ago, g33k said: but ... ducks. Ah, but we have a perfectly good set of ancient debates in the Great Temple of Knowledge on the ancestry of Ducks! http://glorantha.temppeli.org/digest/gd5/1997.08/0740.html And not to forget Soltakss' various 'anthropological' ('anatopological'?) articles at: http://www.soltakss.com/indexmisc.html#Ducks 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
g33k Posted May 2, 2017 Share Posted May 2, 2017 3 hours ago, jajagappa said: Ah, but we have a perfectly good set of ancient debates in the Great Temple of Knowledge on the ancestry of Ducks! http://glorantha.temppeli.org/digest/gd5/1997.08/0740.html And not to forget Soltakss' various 'anthropological' ('anatopological'?) articles at: http://www.soltakss.com/indexmisc.html#Ducks Indeed! Nor can we forget these ducks (no matter how hard we try ... ) ! 1 Quote C'es ne pas un .sig Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ali the Helering Posted May 2, 2017 Share Posted May 2, 2017 9 hours ago, g33k said: but ... ducks. You are refuted. By Humakti bearing the Truth rune, no less! The majestic Durulz are an example of a misunderstood race, despised and rejected for no other reason than speech pattern and external appearance difference. Consider - a strange creature with flappy extremities, bizarre mode of speech, and a tendency to explosions of rage. Ladies and gentlemen, I give you - the Donald! Making Sartar great again..... 4 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ali the Helering Posted May 2, 2017 Share Posted May 2, 2017 I should have added that in the case of this Donald, shouldn't we all Duck? 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
soltakss Posted May 6, 2017 Share Posted May 6, 2017 At the risk of igniting something very bad, there is a thread at rpg.net about rolplaying in Disney's Duckburg. 1 Quote Simon Phipp - Caldmore Chameleon - Wallowing in my elitism since 1982. Many Systems, One Family. Just a fanboy. www.soltakss.com/index.html Jonstown Compendium author. Find my contributions here. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
g33k Posted May 6, 2017 Share Posted May 6, 2017 3 hours ago, soltakss said: At the risk of igniting something very bad, there is a thread at rpg.net about rolplaying in Disney's Duckburg. Am I the only person who envisions going into that thread with a Durulz + UplandMarsh POV, blithely assuming complete intercompatibility? 1 Quote C'es ne pas un .sig Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
M Helsdon Posted December 6, 2017 Author Share Posted December 6, 2017 On 9/1/2016 at 2:43 PM, Steve said: Wow. What are you planning on doing with this when it's done, Martin? Are you going to publish it? And it's 'finished' at 288 pages. Two draft hardbacks (with much marking up as it was my first opportunity to read it on paper) with two Chaosium staffers; my copy marked up; two draft copies in a box. Bits and pieces may appear in the future. The entire thing? I suspect it wouldn't be commercially viable. 4 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Steve Posted December 7, 2017 Share Posted December 7, 2017 11 hours ago, M Helsdon said: Bits and pieces may appear in the future. The entire thing? I suspect it wouldn't be commercially viable. I'm sure it would have viability as a PDF and print-on-demand item. Fingers crossed, and well done Martin. 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
M Helsdon Posted June 3, 2018 Author Share Posted June 3, 2018 Now 321 pages. (Of course most of the appendices could be chopped out). Some material may be appearing in the next Wyrms Footnotes. Introduction......................................... 5 Warfare................................................ 6 Troop Types...................................... 7 Weapons and Armor......................... 9 Non-Human Weapons and Armor.... 35 Unit Organization............................ 36 Innovation...................................... 50 Regional Warfare................................ 52 Pelorian Warfare............................. 53 The Holy Country............................. 63 The Horse Nations........................... 65 Hsunchen Warfare........................... 68 Orlanthi Warfare............................. 68 Praxian Warfare.............................. 74 Other Facets of Warfare.................. 76 Tribute and Taxes............................ 85 The Battlefield.................................... 88 The Battleground............................ 88 Asymmetry..................................... 91 Articulation..................................... 91 Infantry........................................... 91 Cavalry.......................................... 102 Fliers............................................. 111 Chariots......................................... 112 Vexillae......................................... 117 Artillery......................................... 117 Magical.......................................... 118 War Dogs....................................... 119 Warships....................................... 119 Heroes.......................................... 124 Transport and Mobility...................... 125 The Campaign Year........................ 126 Roads and Warfare........................ 129 Water and Warfare........................ 135 Terrain.......................................... 137 Fortifications and Siege Warfare........ 142 Siege Weapons.............................. 142 History of Fortification................... 144 Fortifications................................. 145 Arcane Warfare................................. 159 Religion and Warfare..................... 162 Magical Warfare............................ 162 Gods of War...................................... 180 War Gods of the Lunar Empire........ 183 War Gods of Sartar and Heortland.. 189 War Gods of Esrolia........................ 192 War Gods and Spirits of Prax.......... 193 War Gods of the Horse Nations...... 194 Plates................................................ 196 Armies of Central Genertela.............. 205 Lunar Army.................................... 205 Sartar Free Army............................ 221 Independents................................ 226 Hero Wars Army Lists......................... 239 Lunar Army List.............................. 240 Sartar Free Army List...................... 259 Independents List.......................... 268 Appendices....................................... 284 Beasts of War................................ 284 Temples and Towers...................... 286 Fazzur Wideread............................ 294 The Seshnelan Army...................... 298 Weapon Use.................................. 300 Figures for Gloranthan Armies....... 301 Phalanx Commands....................... 302 Equivalent Military Ranks.............. 303 Index................................................ 307 5 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Akhôrahil Posted February 27, 2021 Share Posted February 27, 2021 Thread necro: is it known when and how the Masassakar Sun Dome Temple was extinguished? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Darius West Posted January 5, 2022 Share Posted January 5, 2022 On 6/13/2016 at 2:09 PM, metcalph said: The Byzantines (whom MOB borrowed for their political stories which he then pumped full of steriods for use in Sun County) had a Patriarch and an Emperor who belonged to the same faith. There was serious political rivalry there. The absence of the High Priests list proves my point. The High Priests are more august than the Counts and so should be reckoned as the real heads of state in Sun County. Despite this, the kids are *not* being taught their names. My feeling as to why there is no list is that many of the High Priests were declared of damnable memory and expunged from the record. People can only get a hint of what might have happened through additions to the lists of Prohibitions over time (5th edition No smoking Hazia! No wearing Red! No multiple marriages!) LOL you forgot "No cross-dressing". This Temporal/Spiritual political dichotomy is repeated in many places IRL history and has been responsible for the ultimate separation of Church and State in a great many countries. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.